My Office Building Has a Vacancy. What Should I Do?

When a tenant leaves an office building, the next decision is not always as simple as finding someone to take their place. You may need to decide whether to update the space, adjust the asking rent, offer improvements, or consider a different type of tenant. If you are thinking about selling the property, the vacancy may also affect how buyers evaluate it.
For owners of traditional office buildings, the challenge is finding the right balance between attracting a new tenant and protecting the property’s long-term financial performance. For medical office owners, the decision can involve additional considerations, particularly when the space has specialized improvements or was designed for a particular type of practice.
A vacant suite can create immediate pressure because expenses continue even when rent stops coming in. However, rushing into a lease or spending heavily on improvements without understanding the market can create a different set of problems.
Before investing more money into the property, it helps to understand what the vacancy means, which options are available, and how each choice fits your plans for the building.

Start by Understanding Why the Space Is Vacant
Before deciding what to change, consider why the previous tenant left and what that tells you about the space.
A tenant may have outgrown the property, downsized, relocated closer to customers, or closed its business. In other cases, the rent, layout, parking, condition, or location may have contributed to the decision.
The distinction matters because not every vacancy requires the same response. If a tenant left because the business expanded beyond the available space, the property itself may not have a significant problem. If several tenants have struggled to renew or attract customers, it may be worth looking more closely at the building’s condition, pricing, and competitive position.
Start by reviewing the previous lease and, when possible, speaking with the departing tenant. Their feedback may help identify issues that weren’t obvious to you as the owner, such as parking difficulties, recurring maintenance concerns, or a layout that no longer supports the tenant’s operations.
For medical office properties, consider whether the previous improvements remain useful to the next occupant. A suite with treatment rooms, sinks, and an appropriate layout may appeal to another compatible practice. A highly specialized space may require substantial changes before it can serve a different provider.
For traditional office space, consider whether the layout, amount of private office space, meeting areas, and overall condition match what prospective tenants are looking for.
The goal is to identify the most likely obstacles to leasing the space before spending money to address them.
Evaluate How Your Space Compares with the Competition
Once you understand the property’s position, look at the other spaces a prospective tenant could consider.
Start with competing buildings in the immediate area. Compare their asking rents, available square footage, condition, parking, amenities, and lease incentives. Pay attention to properties that offer a similar type of space and appeal to the same prospective tenants.
A building with a higher asking rent may still be competitive if it offers better access, updated interiors, or a more functional layout. On the other hand, a property that appears inexpensive may struggle to attract tenants if it requires substantial improvements or does not meet their operational needs.
Medical office space deserves a more specific comparison. A practice may place considerable value on an existing clinical layout, while another provider may prefer a different configuration. The suitability of the improvements, accessibility, parking, and ability to accommodate the intended use can influence how attractive the property is.
Also consider the difference between asking rent and the terms needed to complete a lease. A landlord may advertise one rate but offer free rent, improvement allowances, or other concessions to secure a tenant. (Artie Lucero covers this from the tenant’s side in Tenant Power Play: How Smart Companies Are Using Office Vacancy to Win Better Deals.)
Looking at the full package gives you a better understanding of how your building competes. It also helps you avoid making a decision based solely on another property’s advertised rate.
Local market conditions matter, too. Recent reports illustrate how vacancy can vary across property types and geographic areas. Colliers reported a 17.05% direct office vacancy rate in Salt Lake County in Q2 2026, while Cushman & Wakefield reported a 4.5% overall medical office vacancy rate in its Salt Lake City market at midyear 2026. These figures use different market definitions and reporting periods, so they should not be treated as a direct comparison. However, they reinforce the importance of evaluating medical office and traditional office properties separately and looking beyond a single market-wide statistic.
For an individual property, the more useful question is how it compares with similar spaces in its own submarket. Location, building condition, parking, layout, and the amount of work required before occupancy can all influence how a vacancy performs relative to the broader market.
Decide Whether to Improve the Space or Lease It As-Is
Once you understand the competition, determine whether improvements are likely to make a meaningful difference.
Some vacant suites need little more than cleaning, fresh paint, updated lighting, or minor repairs. These changes may help prospective tenants see the space more clearly without requiring a major investment.
Other properties may need more substantial work. An outdated office layout, aging building systems, or a space that does not meet the needs of likely tenants can make leasing more difficult.
For healthcare properties, improvements may include changes to treatment rooms, plumbing, electrical capacity, or other specialized infrastructure. Before undertaking that work, consider which types of providers are most likely to occupy the space and whether the improvements would serve more than one potential tenant.
Not every improvement will generate enough additional rent or reduce vacancy enough to justify its cost. A more expensive renovation may make the property more attractive, but it can also increase the amount of time and capital required before the investment pays off.
Consider obtaining contractor estimates and comparing the expected cost with realistic leasing assumptions. You should also account for the possibility that the space could remain vacant longer than anticipated.
For example, an owner might compare the cost of making modest cosmetic improvements with the cost of a complete renovation. If the larger project adds only limited leasing appeal, the additional expense may not be justified. If the improvements make the property suitable for a much broader group of tenants, however, a larger investment could be worth evaluating.
In some cases, the best decision is to make modest improvements and let the next tenant customize the space. In others, investing in a more complete renovation may help the property compete more effectively.
A Practical Example: Consider the Possibilities Before Making Changes
In a current office and medical office assignment in Utah Valley, we evaluated how an existing space could serve different types of prospective tenants. Rather than immediately committing to changes, we discussed which improvements the landlord might be willing to make depending on the intended use and the businesses touring the property.
For example, preserving certain existing improvements may make sense for one type of user, while another may benefit from a different layout or targeted modifications. By considering these possibilities before making changes, we were able to identify potential paths forward without assuming that one configuration would work for every prospective tenant.
This approach gives the owner flexibility while helping avoid unnecessary upfront expenses. It also allows the space to be evaluated based on the needs of realistic prospective tenants rather than making costly decisions before understanding which direction offers the best opportunity.
Get a Clear Plan for Your Vacancy
For owners of office and medical office properties throughout Utah, evaluating a vacancy requires more than setting an asking rent and waiting for inquiries. I help property owners assess competing spaces, evaluate leasing and improvement strategies, compare leasing with a potential sale, and determine which approach best aligns with their financial and timing objectives.
Whether you own a traditional office building, a medical office suite, or a healthcare property with specialized improvements, understanding the local market and your available options can help you make a more informed decision about what comes next.
Own an office or medical office building with a vacancy?
Reach out to Chase VanAlfen for a vacancy or market assessment of your property. He’ll look at how your space compares with the competition and help you decide the best next step.

Frequently Asked Questions
What should I do when a tenant leaves my office building?
Start by understanding why the space is vacant: review the previous lease and, if possible, talk with the departing tenant. Then compare the space with competing buildings in the same submarket and decide whether improvements will make a meaningful difference before committing more money.
Should I renovate a vacant office suite before leasing it?
Not always. Some suites only need cleaning, fresh paint, updated lighting, or minor repairs. A larger renovation makes sense when it would make the space suitable for a much broader group of tenants. It can also pay to consider which improvements you’d make for different prospective tenants before committing to one layout.
What makes leasing a vacant medical office suite different?
Medical suites often have specialized improvements like treatment rooms, sinks, plumbing, and added electrical capacity. That buildout can appeal to a compatible practice but may need substantial changes for a different provider, so it’s worth evaluating medical office and traditional office space separately.
What is the office vacancy rate in Salt Lake County?
It depends on the property type. Colliers reported 17.05% direct office vacancy in Salt Lake County in Q2 2026, while Cushman & Wakefield reported 4.5% overall medical office vacancy in its Salt Lake City market at midyear 2026. The reports use different market definitions, so compare your building with similar spaces in its own submarket.
Related Reading
Chase VanAlfen is a commercial real estate broker with Legend Commercial, focused on office and medical office properties throughout Utah.



